Showing posts with label Feminist. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Feminist. Show all posts

Friday, 8 July 2016

Nervous Conditions by Tsitsi Dangarembga

I had been asked, on two different occasions, by two different colleagues who are studying, if I had read this book. Now, I will confess to anyone who asks (except maybe my own kids, should I ever have any), that I was a useless student at university in my undergrad years. I should have read this at university. I remembered that much. But with the exception of one scene, I could remember nothing. (Which probably means that scene was mentioned in a lecture and that I didn't read it.) As luck would have it, I then stumbled across a copy of it at my favourite second hand bookshop (The fact that I didn't already own it also strongly suggests that I didn't read it.). I decided I should remedy that.

“I was not sorry when my brother died.” is the opening line. Set in Rhodesia (Zimbabwe nowadays), this story follows a young Shona girl, Tamba, wanting to be educated. It paints a very clear, and yet complicated, view on the struggles of the people, especially women and girls. Women are meant to serve men. They do not need to be educated. They only need to learn how to cook, grow vegetables and be good, obedient wives. Through Tamba's eyes, we learn not only her story, but the story of her cousin, Nyasha, who spent her formative years in England and who has now returned to Africa; and her aunt, Maiguru, a woman who is educated.

There are books that are written for escapism and enjoyment. And then there are other books. Books that make you judge the characters and their situations, and then turn around and judge yourself. Books that make you ask questions, because things you thought you were sure on, no longer seem that simple. Nervous Conditions falls into this category of book. I have never had a face to face conversation with anyone who has enjoyed this book. For one, everyone who I have spoken to about it had to read it for university, and there is nothing like the words 'prescribed reading' to make even the most avid lover of books dislike reading. But there is a lot more than that that can make a reader not enjoy this one. For starters, it is not a plot driven novel. It is a study of a family, a study of the women in this family, and a study of a patriarch. Secondly, the situation, which is so real and accurate, is so frustrating, and as a reader, one is merely an observer and helpless. The sense of helplessness is only exacerbated because that is exactly the situation Tamba is in. Actually, all the women in this book are helpless to change their situations.

“Can you cook books and feed them to your husband? Stay at home with your mother. Learn to cook and clean. Grow vegetables.”
― Tsitsi Dangarembga, Nervous Conditions

After this point I get a bit spoilery. Although I am basically discussing the themes of the book, but, as the book isn't plot heavy, you should be able to work out a lot. Be warned.

Education. Yes, we preach that through education, one can change their position. But is that really true? If those that have the power do not allow the powerless to have any power, can education make any difference to the powerless? Surely it would be the equivalent of taking a starving man to a feast and telling him he can't eat anything. It was that horrific realisation that really affected me throughout this read. Tamba got to go to school. but at no point did I ever believe that she was free of the life she was destined to live before she had the opportunity. In fact, what was more horrifying, was that I honestly believed that being educated would have only made her future worse, as she would be aware that there was an alternative and her knowledge that she was capable of so much more. Now, we never get to see her future (not in this book at least. Apparently there is a sequel.), so this is me speculating. Although, I think one was meant to. The plight of her cousin, Nyasha, makes the suffering so clear. The situation her aunt is in also confirms this. But more on this later.

The men in Nervous Conditions infuriated me. Jeremiah, Tamba's father, was lazy, he lied, he put his own pleasure first and cared little for his family. And no, I was not expecting Disney-fied bonding sessions out on the lawn with the kids. I am referring to him buying alcohol while his family needed food and clothes - and education. He couldn't be bothered to do repairs on the 'house'. He thought education was a waste of time, and did nothing to encourage his children. But when his brother, Babamukuru, came around, then he was a mewling, supplicant pain in the backside. I suppose this needs a bit of explaining. Babamukuru, being the oldest brother and the wealthiest brother, supported his entire family - which included all his brothers and their families. Whenever Babamukuru arrived on the scene I found my dislike for Jeremiah multiplying. But. This does not mean that I appreciated Babamukuru at all. I used the word 'supplicant' above, because Babamukuru acted as though he was the god of the family. I think he liked having everyone bow down to him (literally) and beg him for scraps, and then praise his generosity for providing. While I do not envy his responsibility, I could not help judging him. Am I being unfair? Would I, in that position, have given more if I were the one working? Would I have also expected people to praise me and thank me? Possibly. But he really annoyed me. Especially considering the position he put Miaguru, his wife, in. After learning that, I felt he was less worthy.

Constantly there is talk in the reading circles I follow about feminism. The need for strong female characters. Well, here is a book with strong female characters; and here is a book that will make all us white women feel we have far less to complain about. To see this struggle was painful; to realise just how indoctrinated the view of feminine inferiority and male superiority was in the culture. Take the issue with another random aunt. She is accused of doing something wrong, and as a result, this needs to be discussed. The men discuss it, while the accused is left outside with all the other women and girls, eavesdropping. But in general, one sees the men giving the boys allowances, whereas one step out of line, one disagreement with the man's wishes, and a girl's entire character is debased. I think the quote below sums up everything much better than I could put it.

“...condemning Nyasha to whoredom, making her a victim of her femaleness, just as I had felt victimised at home in the days when Nhamo went to school and I grew my maize. The victimisation, I saw, was universal. It didn't depend on poverty, on lack of education or on tradition. It didn't depend on any of the things I had thought it depended on. Men took it everywhere with them. Even heroes like Babamukuru did it. And that was the problem. You had to admit Nyasha had no tact. You had to admit she was altogether too volatile and strong-willed. You couldn't ignore the fact that she had no respect for Babamukuru when she ought to have had lots of it. But what I didn't like was the way that all conflicts came back to the question of femaleness. Femaleness as opposed and inferior to maleness.”
― Tsitsi Dangarembga, Nervous Conditions

The effects of colonialism - a difficult subject, because one's own culture and upbringing determines which way of life is 'better'. It is clear that Tamba's mother did not appreciate anything to do with colonialism. Their ancestors were chased off the better land, and they were now, as a result, trying to survive on land that was arid and infertile. She did not appreciate the airs and graces that her niece and nephew had after their return from England, nor her son, when he returned from school. But there was also another side to it. One could not deny that Babamukuru had benefited tremendously. But it was with Nyasha that I felt the most. She was a girl who had spent many years in England. She saw what the alternatives to her culture were and she wanted to embrace it. She did for years. But on returning to Africa, and where she was expected to return to being a diligent Shona girl, she could not make the adjustment. She could not go from knives and forks to eating with her fingers. She could not even remember her own language upon returning. It does not take much imagination to sympathise with her. But her situation with Babamukuru just made it so much worse. The end result for Nyasha still upsets me.

“It’s bad enough . . . when a country gets colonized, but when the people do as well! That’s the end, really, that’s the end.”
― Tsitsi Dangarembga, Nervous Conditions

I must admit that I really wish I had read this at university. I am sure that there is a lot more I would have gained from this book if I had lectures on it and notes to go with. Maybe I can find my file and see what I was given.

I gave this 4 stars because - I don't know. Maybe I should bump it up to a 5 star book. It is clear it did give me a lot to think about. I would recommend this for folks who are interested in reading feminist texts, or folks who are wanting to read diversely and read about different cultures.

Friday, 25 December 2015

The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood

I had heard about this book years ago, and had been hunting for it ever since. I eventually decided to give the audio book a chance while I wait for this elusive book to pitch up somewhere on a shelf where I can buy it.

Offred was not originally her name. She was given this name. In the past she had a different name, was married and had a daughter. All of that has been taken away from her, including her job, her money, her rights - everything. She may not even read. Now Offred is a handmaid. In a world where the birthrate is alarmingly low, it is her duty to fall pregnant and give the family she is currently staying with a baby. As a synopsis, it is sufficient, but it really does not capture the essence of the story.

I have sat here for fifteen minutes with only the first two paragraphs written. What does one say about this book? There is so much to say, and that makes it a daunting task. Ordering my thoughts into some form of structure, eliminating the less relevant parts (after all, I am not writing an essay on this for university) and cutting it into what you, the reader, would like to hear... I don't even know where to start.

Perhaps a brief explanation about myself. I am a feminist and I am an atheist. In other words, if you want to watch me roll around in agony, make me read Milton's Paradise Lost. I OBJECT to the idea that women are responsible for the fall of mankind. OK, soapbox has been kicked under the bed - for now. With luck it will stay there. Actually, bugger that notion. I am a woman and I have a mind of my own. I was not born to please anyone. I will have my say because, if nothing else, Offred and all the other handmaidens didn't - a reminder that while we have voices, we should use them, in case one day, someone tries to take it away from us.

This book provides a shocking look into a theocracy, a theocracy where women are reduced to breeding stock, they are covered from head to toe because "to be seen is to be penetrated", people who disagree with the theocratic system are execute publicly. Folks who say that this could so easily happen have missed a few news broadcasts - it is happening. Some women - although not performing the role of the handmaidens (that is still the wife's job) are living something very close to this. Now. Today. That Atwood sets this in the USA is what really is shocking to us. It is the land of the free. Even in Africa we are brainwashed with American TV to the point that I can honestly say that her choice of setting hits close to home.

“Better never means better for everyone... It always means worse, for some.”
― Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale

If you are looking for a plot driven, pacey novel, you will be disappointed. This narrative, while not boring, is a meandering journey through Offred's life. We see her day to day routines and we have flashbacks of her past. How this change came to be is revealed slowly, in fact, everything is revealed slowly, tantalisingly, forcing one to turn the page to see what happens next or to learn how it happened. I loved the narrative voice in this. The descriptions were pleasing, and even though the book and topic it covers is very dark, there were moments where humour peaked through. For instance when she is discussing the compulsory outfits they are to wear and mentions that some people call them habits, and then agrees that it is a good name because 'habits are hard to break'.

One of the parts that I appreciated the most though was the 'Historical Notes' at the end. It raised a ton of questions for me, and put an entirely different perspective on the story. It was that part that bumped the novel from a 4 star rating to a 5.

“Truly amazing, what people can get used to, as long as there are a few compensations.”
― Margaret Atwood, The Handmaid's Tale

Overall, this book made me cringe. I appreciated that Atwood did not shy away from things. I felt her account, even though of a fictitious 'world' was realistic. Perhaps that is the other part that makes this such a shocking and disturbing book to read - it feels real.

 There really is so much that could be discussed in this. Perhaps it would be a good choice for a feminist book club - or a regular book club because men need to see the other side of the picture too. It could also be interesting to get their input too (because, let's face it, most women will have a similar response to this one. I can't see many agreeing that this is a good thing.)

Friday, 28 August 2015

Beauty Queens by Libba Bray

This was brilliant! Crazy, insane, absurd, but completely brilliant!

A plane full of teen beauty queens crash lands on a deserted tropical island in the middle of nowhere. Sound familiar? If you have read Lord of the Flies by William Golding, it should. Just as Golding created a social experiment on paper, so did Libba Bray. So. Here is the question.  If a group of boys would turn into savages, what would happen to a bunch of beauty queens? Yeah, I went into this convinced that I knew the outcome...


“Maybe girls need an island to find themselves. Maybe they need a place where no one’s watching them so they can be who they really are.”
― Libba Bray, Beauty Queens

Libba Bray has put together the most absurd scenario to create some of the best (non-political) satire I have read.   If you do not like an absurd and crazy plot, then perhaps this one is not for you. If you have a feminist bone in your body, you might be really interested in this. It really raises some interesting questions. I am still puzzling over many statements and occurrences here, and trying to formulate an opinion.

Initially, being a shameful traitor to my own gender, I thought this was going to be a complete spoof on beauty queens, because I wouldn't even qualify as a beauty queen in an alternative universe and have never put any value in females who would qualify (yes, pathetic, I know. I am working on this.). In the beginning I got what I expected - and then, without me even realising it had happened, everything changed. I discovered their individual characters, realised that they weren't morons, and watched them, well, to say would be spoiling, now wouldn't it?

"There was something about the island that made the girls forget who they had been. All those rules and shalt nots. They were no longer waiting for some arbitrary grade. They were no longer performing. Waiting. Hoping.

They were becoming.

They were.”
― Libba Bray, Beauty Queens

While the plot is humorous, the awesome part of this books is everything that it is saying. From the one and only black contestant saying that she is an individual and not a race, to the girls realising their own power. There are some fantastic themes in here.

Contrary to what I expected, this book made me proud to be a female.

I gave this 4 stars on Goodreads. While I absolutely enjoyed this, the rather absurd plot did detract a little, although I believe the plot was the method to transport some really interesting ideas.

This is the 55th book I have read for the 2015 TBR Pile Reading challenge.